I Cheated Before We Were Official - Should I Come Clean About My Infidelity?

September 22, 2023

Relationships are built on trust. When dating someone new, you want to be honest. But what if you did something before committing that could now hurt the relationship? This situation requires thoughtful reflection.

A dating app user faced this dilemma. He met an amazing woman online. They hit it off instantly and started seeing each other exclusively. A month in, he knew she was special. However, he had a brief, meaningless encounter with someone else right before meeting his new partner. He debated whether to tell her.

Here are some things to consider if you were unfaithful before an official relationship:

Look at the Context

There’s a difference between cheating on a committed partner versus a casual hookup before defining the relationship. Consider the circumstances. Were you both still seeing other people at the time? Or did she think you were exclusive earlier than you did?

Examine Your Motives

Before deciding to disclose this or not, understand why you feel compelled to share it. Are you doing it to relieve your own guilt? Or because you genuinely believe she should know to make an informed decision about continuing the relationship? Don't confess just to make yourself feel better. Make sure your reasons are about openness and respect, not self-service.

Consider How She Would React

How do you think your partner would respond if you told her? Would she appreciate the honesty? Or would it only cause unnecessary pain over something she can't change? If the revelation would deeply hurt her or damage the relationship, it may be kinder to keep it to yourself.

Look Forward, Not Backward

The beginning of a relationship is often a gray area. You can't change the past, only control what you do going forward. If you've learned from the experience and plan to be faithful now that you’re committed, focus on building trust. Don’t torpedo a good thing over past mistakes.

Keep Communication Open

If you're unsure whether to disclose it, consider leaving the door open for discussion. You could subtly mention how there was a brief, insignificant situation right before you met. Explain you chose not to get into details since it didn't matter. But invite her to ask questions if she wishes.

Get an Outside Perspective

Don’t try to figure this out alone. Talk to trusted friends or a relationship coach. They may help you gain clarity. If you do decide to tell her, have support in place in case she takes it hard.

Consider Relationship Counseling

If you’re still unsure if confessing would help or harm the relationship, seek advice from a counselor. They can guide you in making the healthiest choice. Counseling can also help overcome infidelity if it surfaces later.

Trust Your Instincts

You know your relationship best. After weighing all considerations, trust your gut. This is a nuanced issue that requires self-reflection. The answer on whether to disclose will become clear by tuning into your wisdom.

In this case, we would advise not telling her about the insignificant encounter before they met. Based on their conversations, he genuinely believes it would only damage her confidence and their budding connection. She is his priority now. Focusing fully on their future together seems healthiest.

Every situation is unique. But these tips can help you make your own thoughtful decision if faced with a similar predicament. With care and maturity, nearly any obstacle in love can be overcome. Compassion and commitment conquer all. The path to love is rarely perfect. What matters most is how devoted you are once you find meaningful connection. With understanding and honesty, stumbles along the way can make you stronger. Have faith and be brave as you walk the journey of relationships. Your efforts will be rewarded in the end.

Work with a Filteroff Matchmaker

Tired of sifting through endless profiles and swiping on dating apps in 2024?

It's time to let a professional Matchmaker do the heavy lifting for you!

Each Filteroff Matchmaker has over 10+ years of proven success in executive matchmaking, ensuring you'll receive curated, high-quality video dates.

Book your free consultation call below and start video dating today!

Here's what you'll get:

✓ Personal human matchmaker
✓ Intake session
✓ Unlimited dating coaching
✓ Unlimited video dates
✓ 90% cheaper than traditional matchmaking services
✓ No swiping, no endless chats

Book Matchmaking Call
*Got questions? Book a consultation call with one of our specialists here